Can a hospital stay make the disease worse? It sounds paradoxical, but of course it can occur as a result of, for example, misdiagnosis and negligence, or of overtreatment. When it comes to psychiatric illnesses and ailments, which are often sensitive to the interaction with the environment, it can be difficult to see how the situation at the hospital affects the illness. Therefore, it is important to be attentive.
A new study by Antoinette Lundahl, carried out together with Gert Helgesson and Niklas Juth, draws attention to the problem in the care of patients who self-harm. They did a survey with healthcare staff at psychiatric clinics in Stockholm. The respondents answered questions about experiences of care longer than a week with this patient group. A majority of the respondents believed that it had detrimental effects on self-injurious behaviour if the patients stayed longer than a week in their ward. They also considered that the patients often stayed too long in the ward and that the reasons for the extended length of stay were in several cases non-medical.
How are we to understand this? How might hospitalization increase the risk of the behaviour to be treated? In the discussion part of the article, various possible explanations are suggested, for example conflicts on the ward or that patients spread self-injurious behaviours to each other. Another possible explanation is that the hospital stay is used by the patient to transfer responsibility for handling painful feelings and thoughts to others. Such avoidance strategies only have a short-term effect and increase the pain in the long term. The self-injurious behaviour can be reinforced as a way to get more care and attention. A kind of “care addiction” develops in the patient, you could say.
How should we understand the extended hospital stays? The respondents mentioned several non-medical reasons, such as uncertainty about the patient’s housing, or that patients who look fragile or are assertive influence the staff to extend the length of care. Another reason for extended care times was assumed to be doctors’ fear of being held responsible for suicide or attempted suicide after discharge, a fear which paradoxically could increase the risk.
Read Antoinette Lundahl’s article here: Hospital staff at most psychiatric clinics in Stockholm experience that patients who self-harm have too long hospital stays, with ensuing detrimental effects.
Then you can also read more about the respondents’ suggestions for improvements, such as giving patients clear care plans with fixed discharge dates, short treatment times (a few days), and information about what is expected of them during the hospital stay. Better collaboration with outpatient care was also recommended, as well as more non-medical treatments in inpatient care.
Antoinette Lundahl, Gert Helgesson & Niklas Juth (2022) Hospital staff at most psychiatric clinics in Stockholm experience that patients who self-harm have too long hospital stays, with ensuing detrimental effects, Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, 76:4, 287-294, DOI: 10.1080/08039488.2021.1965213
We have a clinical perspective